Business strategy
Nick Lawton’s Plan for Testing UGC Before Paid Ads
SideShift co-founder Nick Lawton outlines a $2,000 to $4,000 creator test and explains which audience signals he uses before trying paid distribution.
Listen to the audio analysis
Create your ownWritten for builders and creators.
Scaling a consumer app isn't about having the biggest marketing budget. It's actually about knowing exactly when to stop guessing and start pouring gasoline on the fire.
Editor's note
Why this matters now
Nick Lawton, co-founder of SideShift, proposes spending $2,000 to $4,000 in the first month of a new app's creator program. The aim is to find a repeatable video format before putting a larger budget behind paid distribution.
His Superwall Podcast interview treats that month as a search for content the team can make again, with compensation and screening signals designed around the search. It gives an app founder a concrete proposal to assess. SideShift sells creator-marketing services, so the budget advice also reflects the business he runs.
The source
What it says
Distilled from the original. The notes above and below are the editor's own.
What the First Budget Is Buying
Lawton describes retainers of roughly $600 to $800 for 30 to 60 videos, with additional payments tied to views. The exact number of creators and their output depend on the agreed terms, so the monthly budget should not be read as a fixed package.
He wants several attempts at formats relevant to the app. His suggested starting point is to study content in the same niche and change parts of the hook, script or presentation.
The purpose is to learn whether the team can produce more than one useful video. A single high-view post could reflect a particular subject or performer that the next brief cannot reproduce.
A 5% Engagement Rate Is His Screening Signal
Lawton uses an engagement rate around 5% as a sign that a format deserves further attention. He discusses looking for several videos that clear that level before a paid test.
The interview does not supply a consistent definition of the numerator, denominator or observation window. The percentage therefore cannot function as a universal buying rule. Engagement also does not measure how many viewers installed the app, began a trial or stayed subscribed.
His comments about AI-generated UGC illustrate the distinction. Lawton says he has not seen it convert well in the cases he follows. In one example, viewers reacted to the fact that a video was AI-generated rather than asking about the product.
That is a useful question to ask of a comment section: what attracted the response? It remains his observation, not evidence that AI-generated video can never sell an app.
The Paid Test Answers a Different Question
Lawton suggests moving promising organic videos into a bounded paid test before increasing spend. The earlier organic response provides a candidate creative. The paid campaign then needs to show what acquiring customers with that video costs.
For an app already spending more than roughly $10,000 a month across organic and paid marketing, he proposes $100 a day across the selected videos, not for each video. His example uses 14 days, with the test length depending on whether the app offers a 7-day or 14-day trial. Those conditions make it a proposed test for that situation, rather than a minimum budget for every app.
A paid test adds a cost that organic engagement alone cannot justify. The decision to expand depends on the customers acquired and the revenue they produce, including what happens after the initial trial. The interview does not provide a complete acquisition model for a new app.
He favours Meta for the B2B advertising he discusses. The interview does not establish a current, comprehensive comparison of Meta and TikTok advertising features or attribution. Neither platform preference nor an organic engagement rate supplies a return calculation for another app.
Joseph Choi's organic-to-paid discussion explains the related division of strategy, creator coaching and recruiting. It adds the team responsibilities behind the handoff between content and paid testing.
Budget Shares and Creator Assignments Are Different
Lawton describes larger operations putting roughly 20% of marketing spend into content creation and 80% into paid performance. Separately, he suggests directing most creators toward an established format while a smaller group keeps testing alternatives.
The two allocations answer different questions. One divides money between production and distribution. The other divides creative effort between repeating and exploring. Neither requires a small app to adopt the same proportions before it has a working format or a measured customer-acquisition cost.
Nomadtable's creator network offers a contrasting account in which per-view creator payments carry more of the distribution work. It shows why the channel mix depends on the product and audience, rather than a fixed maturity ladder.
Editor's note
What to do with this
Lawton's proposed first month buys information about content: which demonstrations hold attention, prompt product interest and can be made again. The next paid test buys information about acquisition cost. Treating those as separate questions makes the transition easier to judge.
A video can pass the first test and fail the second. People may watch and respond without becoming customers at a sustainable cost. That is why Lawton’s engagement signal can nominate a candidate for an ad test, while the resulting customer economics determine whether it deserves more budget.
The original
#1 UGC EXPERT Reveals How To Market Consumer Apps
The Superwall Podcast · 3 August 2026
Read next
Business strategy
Nomadtable: How Jay Raavi Runs a 60-Creator Network
Jay Raavi explains how he tests videos before briefing creators, what he watches in retention data and why managing the network still takes work.
3 min read8 min listen
Business strategy
Canyon Pergande on Growing an App in a Tiny Niche
SideShift’s Canyon Pergande connects a narrow audience with creator-program decisions: finding a format, choosing the next hire and testing paid ads.
4 min read7 min listen