Business strategy

Dan Vykhopen: Massive's 50,000-Email Waitlist Fell Flat

Massive’s waitlist brought few users, and one word in a video hook changed who watched. Dan Vykhopen explains the gap between attention and demand.

Listen to the audio analysis

Create your own

Written for builders and creators.

Dan Vykhopen collected roughly 40,000 to 50,000 email addresses for Massive before launching its job-application app. About half a percent even signed up for the finished product, he says. Payment was another step beyond that.

Editor's note

Why this matters now

Dan Vykhopen is the founder of Massive. In this Superwall Podcast interview, published 3 October 2025, he describes building its AI job-application app and learning how hard it is to turn attention into paying customers.

His team collected roughly 40,000 to 50,000 waitlist signups. About half a percent even signed up for the launched product, he says. Payment was a further hurdle.

If you're using a waitlist to decide whether to build, that distinction matters. Dan's story gives you a sharper question to ask of your own launch, plus a surprisingly specific example of a video reaching the wrong audience.

Recording updated, 3 November 2026: The replacement distinguishes product signups from payments and attributes the $2 million annual recurring revenue figure to the episode's introduction. The earlier recording used unsupported monthly recurring revenue wording. Revenue remains self-reported.

Company update, 30 October 2026: Massive's current site promotes expert sourcing and company-data licensing for AI labs. It also still links to its job-application service. The interview and audio below cover the earlier app-growth story. For the current sourcing business, read our explanation of Massive's AI-lab services.

The source

What it says

Distilled from the original. The notes above and below are the editor's own.

The Waitlist Looked Like Demand

A LinkedIn post about using AI for job applications attracted attention. Dan describes spending around 2 months building the product while collecting tens of thousands of email addresses.

At launch, very few became users. In his account, about 0.5% signed up, with almost no payment from the list. Signing up and becoming a paying customer are separate steps.

He then had to find people who would pay and give feedback. His conclusion is blunt: he would spend the validation period trying to sell a small version of the product.

For a new app, he proposes a $1,000 to $2,000 influencer test with a clear pitch. The interview provides no acquisition cost or guaranteed result for that proposed experiment.

One Word Changed Who Watched

Dan describes two similar hooks:

  • “Stop using LinkedIn to apply to jobs.”
  • “Stop using Indeed to apply to jobs.”

The LinkedIn version reached more of the white-collar job seekers Massive wanted, he says. The Indeed version could still attract views, but it brought a different audience and almost no conversion.

His explanation is audience selection. The platform named at the beginning helped determine who stayed to watch and why they responded.

That is more useful than a blanket instruction to make better content. Your hook may be working perfectly at attracting people who will never want your product.

Explain the Product Quickly

Dan calls Massive Tinder for jobs. The familiar comparison gives him a short way to explain matching people with jobs and applying on their behalf.

He contrasts it with longer descriptions of automation and features. The point is whether the person seeing the video understands what the product would do for them.

He also favors adapting formats that have already worked, alongside a smaller share of new ideas. Those are his practices for this consumer app. The interview supplies no controlled comparison showing the same mix will work for another product.

Views Still Need to Become Customers

The episode connects the waitlist problem with the hook problem. Both can produce encouraging attention while leaving the business short of buyers.

For another example of that gap, read the Coconote founders on growth and onboarding. If you're choosing a creator test, the Superwall creator-marketing playlist covers payment terms, targeting and conversions across other app stories.

Editor's note

What to do with this

Before increasing your content budget, follow one campaign through views, visits, signups and payments. Find the step where people disappear, then use the interview's examples to choose what to investigate.

Compare Dan's waitlist with Caleb Dean's paid prelaunch test and Roger Chen's ads for a mockup. They ask different questions about demand. See how the 3 examples differ in our guide to app demand tests. The launch-and-sell playlist brings those audio analyses together.

The original

This app makes $2m/year using this ridiculously easy strategy

The Superwall Podcast · 3 October 2025

All posts